Care Partnering, Challenges & Solutions, Love

harry and the daughter who never visited

I don’t know if the story/parable below is true or not, but I think it could be. I’ve written it based on a comment someone shared in a caregivers’ group on Facebook. One thing is sure, the lesson it contains is powerful, practical and hopeful.

Harry, who lived with Alzheimer disease, was moved into a large nursing home somewhere in the world because his family couldn’t take care of him anymore. Every Saturday, a young woman would come to visit. She always brought delicious ice cream for Harry and her to share. Harry loved ice cream. He loved the feel of the cool creaminess in his mouth, and he enjoyed tasting the different flavours: raspberry, vanilla, chocolate, and maple, which was his favourite.

He and the young woman savoured their bowls of ice cream together, and chatted about things Harry didn’t remember after she left. But each week his face lit up like a Christmas tree when she walked into his room. He was glad to see her because he often felt lonely. Even though there seemed to be lots of people around, none of them sat and talked to Harry like the young woman who brought the ice cream did. No one seemed to pay much attention to him but her.

These Saturday visits went on for several months. Then, at the end of their visit on the last Saturday in July, Harry said something to the young woman that made her terribly sad.

“My daughter never comes to visit,” Harry said. His eyes got watery, his chin started to quiver, and his voice cracked. “I think she’s forgotten me. She mustn’t care if I live or die. I wish she would come to see me like you do.”

The young woman was devastated by Harry’s words. Her heart broke in two on the spot. She had to do something to help Harry feel better.

The next week, when she came to visit, bringing ice cream as usual, she also brought an envelope, which she surreptitiously placed on Harry’s bedside table when she came in. After they’d had their treat, the young woman drew Harry’s attention to the envelope.

“It looks like you got a letter Harry,” she said. “I wonder who it’s from?”

“I don’t know,” Harry said.

“Shall we take a look?” the young woman asked.

Harry nodded. The young woman fetched the envelope from the side table. “It says ‘Dad’ on the front.” She handed the envelope to Harry, who took if from her with a slight frown on his face. “Open it,” said the young woman. “Let’s see what it says.”

Harry pulled a handwritten note from the envelope and read it to himself. A smile spread across his face.

“What does it say?” asked the young woman.

“It says ‘Hi Dad, I dropped in to see you today, but you were out. You must have been at the barbershop with Joe and Charlie when I came by. But don’t worry, I’ll come again next week, and I’ll bring some ice cream to share. See you then, Love Katherine.’”

Harry was beaming. “Katherine’s my daughter,” he said to the young woman. “She came to see me today, but I must’ve been out. She says she’s coming back next week. She’s going to bring ice cream. She’s loved ice cream since she was a little girl.”

“Oh Harry, that’s great news,” said the young woman, “I’m sure your daughter loves you very much, and she’ll be here just as she promised.”

It went on like this every week for several months. Anytime Harry felt sad that his daughter never came to visit, the young woman would draw his attention to an envelope somewhere in the room. The notes were slightly different each time: perhaps Harry was in the bathroom, or the garden, or at the dentist, or wherever when Katherine had come by. But the promise was always the same: next week, his daughter would be back, and she would bring ice cream.

Meanwhile, the young woman and Harry enjoyed many Saturday afternoons together talking about his childhood, the weather, and the birds in the feeder by the window. Sometimes the young woman read to Harry. Sometimes he told her war stories. They joked and laughed about nothing. Then, one Saturday in December, Harry’s face lit up like a Christmas tree just as it always did when the young woman walked into the room. But this time, it was different.

“Katherine!” Harry exclaimed. “I’m so glad to see you.”

“Hi Dad,” the young woman said as she gave him a big hug. “I’m happy to see you too. I brought you some ice cream. Maple, your favourite.” They spent a wonderful afternoon laughing, listening to music, singing and just being together. Harry told Katherine about the young woman who sometimes came to visit, and who also brought ice cream.

“She’s very nice,” Harry said earnestly. “But not as nice as you Katherine. You’re my daughter. No one can take your place.” Katherine reached out for Harry’s hand, squeezed it gently, and looked into his eyes. “I love you, Dad,” she said.

“I love you too sweetie,” Harry replied. “Always remember that. No matter what.

I visited with my mom virtually every day for the last four years of her life, and I was with her when she died. Sometimes she recognized me, sometime she didn’t. But it didn’t matter. What mattered was that we got to spend time together, and we created moments of joy almost every day. Just like Harry and Katherine.

#mc_embed_signup{background:#fff; clear:left; font:14px Helvetica,Arial,sans-serif; }
/* Add your own MailChimp form style overrides in your site stylesheet or in this style block.
We recommend moving this block and the preceding CSS link to the HEAD of your HTML file. */

Subscribe to MAS now & get 5 free PDFs & a page of welcome links:

Email Address

Take my short survey on behaviour here.

Image copyright: bialasiewicz / 123RF Stock Photo>

7 thoughts on “harry and the daughter who never visited”

  1. Thank you for sharing this story… really touched my heart. You see, I also took care of my mother throughout her Alzheimer’s and although she really didn’t know me anymore, she loved my company and I loved hers. I am now an Elder Care Manager assisting those who can’t care for themselves and I chose to do this because there are so many elders here without family who need some ice cream.


    1. Thanks Good Daughter. I think we always know each other at a soul level. And I too have personally witnessed the fact that “there are so many elders here without family who need some ice cream.”

      Thanks for all you do.


  2. that is a beautiful story susan. brought tears to my eyes.

    blessings to you for all the good work that you do.

    my MIL got placed in a new home a few weeks ago – it’s one of those where there are animals and lots of activities for her to participate in. hopefully this will prolong her for a few more years.

    and perhaps she’ll start to remember us when we visit.


    1. Thanks Annie. I’m sure there are many stories like this out there, we just don’t hear about them.

      I’m so glad your mother-in-law has been relocated to what sounds like a better place. I hope she’ll be happy there and that you’re able to share many more good times together.


  3. Wow that made my eyes leak. Mother in law is in a home and told us about two grandsons who dont visit, not the ones who are men but the little ones. Of course they are the same.


  4. Beautiful story Susan! My mom didn’t recognize me as her daughter any more in the last few years of her life, but her face always lit up when she saw me. She loved me, and knew I loved her. That is really all that matters. When the person you love no longer recognizes you it is possible to build a new loving relationship.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s